2nd Opinion

2nd Opinion

Share this post

2nd Opinion
2nd Opinion
Seeing Red, not Blue

Seeing Red, not Blue

The 'winter dike' position, more authoritarian government and democracy in the time of Covid-19.

2nd Opinion's avatar
2nd Opinion
Sep 04, 2020
∙ Paid

Share this post

2nd Opinion
2nd Opinion
Seeing Red, not Blue
Share

A policy of “extreme containment” by a government primed to move faster than democrats or scientists is the best response to coronavirus, says Wim Schellekens, a former Chief Inspector of the Health Care and Youth Inspectorate. But critics of a new Corona Act say it turns democratic principles upside down - op hun kop - by giving ministers powers normally reserved for a state of emergency.  

In an interview with Trouw, Schellekens described corona policy in biblical terms: if the trumpet sounds a muffled call - “Indien de bazuin een onduidelijk geluid geeft” - who will prepare for battle? (Numbers 10:9). He argues for a precautionary principle, meaning a more authoritarian government willing to act on the basis of strong suspicion before any hard scientific evidence.

Why, he asked rhetorically, do guidelines always take the form of recommendations: En waarom is alles een aanbeveling?

In the red corner

Schellekens has assembled an unofficial group of 12 experts, known as the Red Team. Re…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Leaders' Bureau
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share